Jump to content
Atul Patankar

Air India leased defective aircraft

Recommended Posts

Atul Patankar

As reported by Saurabh Sinha & Himanshi Dhawan at timesofindia.indiatimes.com on 4 October 2009


NEW DELHI: Thanks to Right to Information, shocking instances of mismanagement over the years are now coming to light that show how Air India's Maharaja has now been reduced to a pauper. A query filed by RTI activist S C Agrawal has led to confirmation of what was till now a whisper - expensive aircraft lease (rent) deals being made by the airline with these agreements favouring rental companies and not AI.


The airline has admitted to renting at least two aircraft that did not prove to be airworthy or safe to fly and then losing over $29 million while terminating the lease agreement prematurely.


This particular case dates back to 1996 when AI took two aircraft from West Indian company Caribjet. One of the aircraft, an Airbus A-310, developed technical snags time and again. The situation came such a point that the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) had to ask AI to stop using that aircraft. In its reply, AI has given a letter written by DGCA to the airline in September 1996 about the aircraft (VT-LEJ, the A-310) which says: "The aircraft is having repeat nature of defects despite maintenance action... AI should consider not to utilise the said aircraft as (its) airworthiness/safety of operation cannot be ensured (sic)."


This aircraft had a host of problems. On two occasions, it had to return to land soon after taking off. It got delayed at Heathrow for days due to a problem in the cargo door and defects in fuel quantity indicator. After the DGCA warning, AI wrote to Caribjet about early termination of leases of this aircraft and another one hired from the same company (VT-LEK). By doing so, reveals the RTI reply filed by the airline, AI had to pay a whopping $23.6 million to Caribjet and an additional $6 million as interest!


While AI has owned up to one costly error, questions on its lease policy are still being raised. Three years back, the AI-IA combine placed orders for 111 new aircraft, including the yet-to-fly Boeing Dreamliner 787. The massive shortage of aircraft during the times of the aviation boom ” that was busted by last year's global recession and Indian slowdown ” led AI to take many aircraft on lease from foreign companies. But since there were no pilots to fly them, the planes remained idle at Indian airports while the Maharaja continued shelling out money to the companies.


Source: Air India leased defective aircraft - India Business - Business - NEWS - The Times of India

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Similar Content

    • karira
      By karira
      Recently I booked tickets on Air Deccan and Indigo for my mother.
      The tickets were booked on yatra.com and paid for by Credit Card.
      The cost of the ticket was shown as "Passenger Fare" and "Taxes". The taxes are approximately Rs. 1725.00 for each ticket.
      From experience, I know that these "Taxes" include Passenger Service Fee, Airport Tax, User Charges, Fuel Surcharge, Additional Fuel Surcharge, Security Charges, etc...."
      Due to health reasons, my mother could not make the trip.
      While cancelling the tickets, BOTH the airlines deducted the "passenger fare" part of the cost (which is correct, since the tickets were clearly non-refundable). However, BOTH the airlines told me that for the "taxes" part, they will only issue a voucher that can be used by the same passenger within 180 days and on the same airline.
      My thinking is that all these so called "taxes" become payable when a passenger actually travels. These "taxes" are collected by the airline, on behalf of the Government and to be paid to the Government when the passenger actually flies. They cannot collect taxes, not pay to the Government and moreover not refund to the passenger, but ask him to utilize this amount through a voucher which is non-transferable.
      Some research showed me that both Air Deccan and Indigo owe the Government huge amounts in taxes which they have not paid and also owe large amounts to the Airports Authority of India (AAI) for parking fees, navigation fees etc, which also they have not paid and are long overdue.
      I would like to know the following information through a RTI :
      1. When do these "taxes" actually become due ?
      That means , when are the airlines actually supposed to pay to the Government or the appropriate authority ? Are they supposed to pay the Government within a stipulated time period of collecting the amount OR only after a passenger flies ?
      2. Can someone collect taxes on behalf of the Government , not pay the Government and then also not pay back the passenger ?
      3. What are the relevant rules under which, someone who collects money on behalf of the Government and misuses the funds, can be penalised ?
      4. How much do these airlines (and others too) owe the Govt. on "taxes" and AAI on other charges ?
      Since how long are these payments overdue ?
      What action has the Govt. or AAI taken against these airlines ?
      If no action, why not ?
      When will action be taken ?
      Whom should I address my RTI application to ?
      Ministry Of Finance, Ministry of Civil Aviation, DGCA or AAI ?
      Can members please guide me.
      I was told that these procedures are in place by most airlines since mid October. Members and guests should bear this aspect in mind before booking tickets and check with the airline before paying for a ticket.
    • vasu_m_r
      By vasu_m_r
      How does one go about finding the breakup of the taxes on our tickets ? I read somewhere that airlines charge it as tax and pocket the money. I would like to know how to find out more about it !


  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy