Jump to content

Probe into 200 unnatural deaths in Goa await test report

Recommended Posts


As reported in bombaynews.net on 03 June 2008:

Probe into 200 unnatural deaths in Goa await test report


Probe into 200 unnatural deaths in Goa await test report


Investigations into nearly 200 cases of unnatural death in Goa have been bogged down mainly on account of delays in receiving viscera test results of the bodies, conducted in laboratories outside the state.


Cases have been pending from as far back as April 2006, M.K. Desai of the Office of the Superintendent of Police, Crime, Dona Paula, said in response to a Right to Information (RTI) query raised by this correspondent.


This issue has repeatedly come up in Goa, but it did so more dramatically following the February 2008 death of British tourist Scarlett Keeling. The 15-year-old was found dead - suspected to have been drugged, raped and killed - on a North Goa beach.


In the two-year period, Goa with a 1.4 million population found 197 cases pending, causing delays in investigations due to delays in these crucial viscera analyses.


Viscera refer to the internal organs of the body, especially those within the chest or abdomen.


In death cases where the precise cause and nature of death -- whether suicide or homicide -- is not yet determined, viscera tests are awaited till the precise cause of death is pinpointed.


Medical texts say usually viscera to be preserved from the body includes the stomach with its full contents, about one foot of the upper part of the intestine, half or 500 gm of the liver, half of each kidney and the whole spleen.


Currently, cases of Goa's viscera tests are being sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory at Vidhyanagari-Santa Cruz in Mumbai. Earlier, the these were sent to Hyderabad, where the large backlog is now visible.


Foreigners' deaths, for obvious reasons, result in higher publicity. Nearly 32 of the 'viscera test pending' cases pertain to foreigners.


Among the foreigners whose deaths are mostly still shrouded in mystery, due to viscera test pending status, are Maria Helstron, Richard Miler and Barbara Lane (October 2006), Den Ratliffo and Stuart Bell (February 2007), Frank Bringloc and Andrew White (March 2007), Olg Gorshkar, Joseph Yougert, James Elister, Bonny Dayhle, Aben Leonard, Maralin Bekwad, Sen Joseph, Otto Zizga, Has Jomsodi and Reic Harrison (all in Apr 2007).


Other foreign cases involve Willhelmine Black, Denise Higgins and Berd Zerreben (June 2007), Alvdar Gaslin (July 2007), Flavia D'zulo and Brian Dowes (both September 2007), Karus Helmet (October 2007), and Weis F. Madas (December 2007).


Likewise, cases of Evgeny Kuzmin, Gillian Frances Bell, Krister Lundh, Alexander Sokolov, Karl T. Milling, and Victor Pristavki (all six in Jan 2008) are among those whose names suggest a foreigner connection in the 'viscera report awaited' cases.


Besides the above listed cases, the high-profile case of Scarlett Keeling, pending from March 18 this year, is the only one sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory at Vidyanagari in Mumbai.


While the lack of testing facilities here is obviously delaying investigations in cases, some believe it is better to let the tests be carried out in central or out-of-state institutions to reduce the chances of results being manipulated locally.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Similar Content

    • sidmis
      By sidmis
      IGP, SP issued notices by state information panel
      As reported in Navhind Times, NT NETWORK Tuesday, June 3, 2008
      MAPUSA The State information Commission has issued notices to the IGP, Mr Kishan Kumar and the superintendent of police (headquarters), Mr Allan D’sa on an appeal filed by the dismissed PSI, Mr Nerlon Albuquerque.

      The dismissed PSI filed an appeal before the State Information Commission after his request to Mr D’sa who is the public information officer and the IGP who is the first appellate authority was turned down.

      It may be recalled that Mr Nerlon was dismissed from service over the infamous Scarlette case based on an inquiry conducted by DySP, Mr Nilu Raut Desai wherein Mr Nerlon was indicted for improper investigations and treating the case as a mere suicide. Raising doubts over the authenticity and genuineness of the inquiry conducted against him without seeking his presence, Mr Nerlon had sent a notice to the SP (HQ) and IGP requesting them to furnish the inquiry report. His request was turned down.

      When contacted Mr Nerlon said that not taking his statement during the course of inquiry and now by not providing him the inquiry report clearly speaks about the malicious motives of the concerned officers and added that it is obvious that the enquiry is conducted in a biased manner with the sole intention of dismissing him.
      “It seems that the IGP is trying to safeguard interests of certain persons by not allowing a fair enquiry in the matter. Why else did he dismiss me and scuttle the process of the enquiry?” Mr Nerlon questioned.

      Reiterating his demand for a fair enquiry, Mr Nerlon stated that he wanted the enquiry to be conducted by an independent body given the fact that the police department would be pressurized under the influence of the IGP in conducting a biased enquiry.

      Mr Nerlon further challenged the IGP to show any significant investigation conducted in the case after the investigation was taken over from him. "In spite of several requests, why did the superiors not permit me to register an offence and arrest the accused?" he asked.

      The IGP allegedly has been pressurized by certain vested interests to dismiss me and I will not take this lightly,” Mr Nerlon added.
    • karira
      By karira
      As reported in bombaynews.net on 06 June 2008:
      Goa opens assembly committee meetings to public, media
      Goa opens assembly committee meetings to public, media
      The Goan media and public got a pleasant surprise here when they were allowed to sit through an assembly committee meeting, directly getting to hear from those in power.
      'It was quite a surprising experience (to allow the public at a committee meeting). But there were few people present perhaps because they were not expecting it, or not aware,' said lawyer Avinash Bhosle, a corporator from Panaji and former student leader, who was present at the meeting.
      A Goa secretariat employee who was present for a meeting, said: 'A journalist argued against the setting up of a landfill garbage dump near her home, but the opposition leader had a different point of view.'
      Assembly committees are set up to discuss issues of governance and comprise legislators from various parties.
      'Going one step further, the speaker also enabled members of the media and the public to state their views before the committee on matters under their consideration,' said an official.
      Goa has made another effort to revive its committees that had fallen into disuse for a decade. Not just that, in April, Speaker Pratapsing Rane threw open all state legislative assembly committees to the media and the public here.
      But there are restrictions, and the media and citizens cannot ask 'any question or seek any reply either from the committee or from the official witness appearing' before it. The panel chairman has powers to issue orders to the media and citizens.
      Speaker Rane has plans to 'rewrite rules of the house and the committees' to meet current needs, to make members testify before committees in place of officers, telecast committee proceedings live, and permit the committees to sit at places outside the assembly - a huge and costly building that is located just outside Panaji but sometimes considered far from some parts of rural Goa.
      Goa assembly secretary R. Kothandaraman said the speaker also plans to create 'parliamentary NGOs' to 'enable the legislative assembly to reach out to the masses'.
      Kothandaraman, who has served in the national parliament too, points out that the Indian constitution does not speak 'elaborately' about committees, as it does about the whole house. Committees are fairly operational at the parliamentary (federal) level, but dormant in many state legislatures, he says.
      'As an effective committee system is perceived as a threat to state governments, committees are either suspended or scrapped or made non-functional,' Kothandaraman admits.
      Incidentally, Rane is also credited with taking the initiative to pass Goa's early Right to Information Act in 1997 that worked well for a while before it got grounded in lethargy and political cum bureaucratic sabotage.


  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy