Jump to content
Atul Patankar

Rs 175 per sq ft for Borivli plot

Recommended Posts

Atul Patankar

As reported by Varun SIngh at mid-day.com on 17 Sept 2010


That's the rate at which housing society got collector's 3,080-sq-ft disputed land


A 3,080-ft plot in the prime location of LT Road in Borivli (W) was given away by the government to a housing society for a throwaway price of Rs 5,39,000. This comes to a measly Rs 175 per sq ft, when the going rate in the area is between Rs 8,000 and Rs 10,000 per sq ft.


The land belongs to the collector and it has been given to a group of 11 members under the banner Swami Samarth Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. RTI documents available with MiD DAY show that nine of the 11 members are government officials and one works in a nationalised bank and the other in a semi-government organisation.


The deal, according to papers available with MiD DAY, was finalised in October last year. However, the name of the society was put on the property card in February this year. According to the collector, the land has been leased to the society with rights of occupancy and development.


The Bhandari family, who occupy a small portion on the controversial land, have taken this matter to court. Advocate Vinod Sampat, who is representing the Bhandaris, said, "The land has been occupied by a family for nearly 40 years. The government has to first acquire the property to allot it to someone else, which was not done. The government in a haste has handed over the property to some co-operative society and that too at throwaway prices."


The Bhandaris say

The Bhandaris claim that they have been staying on the same land for the last 40 years. "The electricity bill, the property tax receipt, ration card and other important documents bear the family's names. How can the government one day decide to give away the land to someone else, without informing us? A few men came to survey the property in August, after which we approached the court, which ordered a stay on the whole thing," said Rakesh Shetty, legal advisor for the Bhandaris.


Shetty further added, "The Bhandaris also own a small flower shop in the premises, for which they have the required licences and permissions."


Shetty further claims that when they investigated about the members of Swami Samarth Society, they found that they already have flats in their names.


"These people want to develop a building over here and exploit it commercially and even destroy the garden within the premises, along with nearly 25 trees that are decades old," he added.


The law states that if one has a house in their name in Mumbai limits, the person cannot avail of any housing scheme under the government.


The Other Side

Collector (Suburbs), Mumbai, Nirmal Kumar Deshmukh, believes there is nothing wrong with the whole deal.


He said, "There are certain clauses under which the government can allot land to co-operative societies at a concession. In this case too, the government has allotted the plot to the society under the same rule."


When MiD DAY asked him if he knew who the members were and whether he was aware that there are allegations that some members already owned flats, he said, "The moment there are complaints against any of the members, I will surely initiate action," said Deshmukh.


Vaishali Vaid, one of the members of Swami Samarth, who owns a house in Borivli, said, "I am not the only member.


Why don't you talk to the secretary?" When asked to provide the secretary's phone number, she said she didn't have it.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Similar Content

    • sidmis
      By sidmis
      RTI fallout: Collector fined
      as reported by Faizan Ahmad,TNN 12 Oct 2008, Times of India
      Cartoonist R K Laxman’s common man is no longer a hapless commoner. Armed with a constitutional weapon provided by the Right To Information (RTI) Act, he is now empowered enough to expose the powers-that-be and ensure the erring ones among them are taken to task.
      This is exactly what Ram Pravesh Rai has been doing for sometime now. This 48-year-old farmer from Buxar has almost dedicated his life to dig out the truth buried in official files and expose the erring babus. Thanks to his relentless efforts, a district magistrate (DM), who once sent him to jail, has been fined by the State Information Commission (SIC).
      The former Buxar DM, Vishnudeo Prasad, was fined Rs 25,000 by name and the money has since been deducted from his salary. His successor in Buxar was also slapped a fine of an equal amount. But at a later meeting of the full bench of SIC, the recovery of fine from the present DM has been stayed.
      Rai, an activist of Soochna Ka Adhikar Manch, is often seen carrying a heavy bundle of photocopies of official documents he has procured through RTI, and even a cursory look at these documents provides enough evidence of corruption, embezzlement of government funds and evasion of taxes worth several crores of rupees in Buxar district alone.
      The information he has secured concerns implementation of three government-sponsored schemes - Million Shallow Tubeless Yojana, Pradhan Mantri Rojgar Yojana and the scheme for loan to purchase tractor - during the last six to seven years.
      "What is surprising is that such corrupt practices continued not only during the RJD regime but also under the ‘sushasan’," rued Rai, showing the documents. Chief minister Nitish Kumar too knows most officials do not want to supply information to public. "Justice can be provided to people through RTI but the problem is that some officials with old mindset are hesitant to make official information public," he once said at a function of SIC.
      Noted social activist Parveen Amanullah, the founder head of `Soochna Ka Adhikar Manch’, said since the information dissemination mechanism is still in a very early stage, it is not functioning satisfactorily. "The officials are supposed to keep details readily available but they are not doing it," she said.
      SIC spokesman Rambadan Baruah admitted that certain officials are still hesitant to share information with people. "The scenario has changed after the commission ordered posting of public information officers in each department and government offices," he said.
      RTI fallout: Collector fined-Patna-Cities-The Times of India
    • sidmis
      By sidmis
      Bikaner collector fails to reply under RTI, fined as reported in Times of India, TNN, JAIPUR: Jun 5, 2010, The chief information commissioner (CIS), Rajasthan, S D Kaurani, has imposed a penalty of Rs 25,000 on district collector of Bikaner for failing to answer some questions under the RTI. The matter relates to an application filed by one Sripal Jain on December 11, 2008 seeking information regarding deployment of election officers in Bikaner (west) assembly segment during the 2008 Vidhan Sabha polls. The applicant had sought information like names of poll duty employees, whose duties were cancelled, on what ground duties were cancelled, details of the officers who performed their duties, details of employees on duty in all the seven assembly segments of Bikaner during the 2008 assembly polls. The CIS has directed the Bikaner collector to deposit the amount within 30 days and extract the amount from the official responsible for the lapse. Besides, the commissioner has asked the collector to give all information sought by the applicant within the next 10 days. Bikaner collector fails to reply under RTI, fined - Jaipur - City - The Times of India


  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy