Jump to content
Atul Patankar

In RTI reply, DoT says unaware of case in SC

Recommended Posts

Atul Patankar

As reported by Himanshi Dhawan at timesofindia.indiatimes.com on Nov 15, 2010


NEW DELHI: The department of telecom is playing coy about the 2G spectrum case in Supreme Court. Faced with an RTI petition about the embarrassing case, it batted aside the query taking shelter behind technicalities, and passed the buck to the PMO.


On the flip side, the PMO replied — with uncharacteristic promptness — within hours to the very same query stating clearly that PM and his office were aware of the matter relating to allotment of 2G spectrum before the SC.


RTI activist S C Agrawal had asked DoT if PM or PMO was aware of the 2G spectrum case, the names of the parties in court, whether Union minister A Raja was party to the case in his official or personal capacity and whether advocates representing him were being paid for by the minister or by a public authority.


In a reply dated November 9, the telecom ministry's CPIO R K Gupta said, "It is observed that no specific court case has been mentioned for which the information has been sought." Using the plea that the information sought pertained to the PMO, Gupta said "information can be provided by this office only after the information furnished by PMO".


Significantly, PMO in its reply dated the same day said, "The PM/PMO are aware that the matter relating to allotment of 2G spectrum is before the SC." The response from telecom department comes at a time when a CAG report submitted recently estimated that the public exchequer incurred a revenue loss of Rs 1.76 lakh crore.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Similar Content

    • ganpat1956
      By ganpat1956
      New Delhi. Dec. 29: The email lying on the desk of the information commissioner isn’t the classical hate message, but its sender has no love lost for the Central Information Commission.
      “You won’t get away with this,” reads a line in the anonymous message. The information commissioner the email is addressed to dismisses it as an “empty threat”, but concern is writ large on his face. It’s not the first case, after all.
      Central information commissioners have been at the receiving end of several “personal slanders” — from “empty threats” to allegations of “motivated judgments — in the past two months. “While most mails are anonymous, some government officials have been brazen enough to reveal their identities,” says a joint secretary at commission.
      Initially, some information commissioners laughed it off. “It’s ugly, but you have to shrug it off. After all, they are bureaucrats, not goondas (thugs) and it didn’t seem a major cause for concern,” said an information commissioner who received two mails where the sender identified himself.
      But now, there are worries. The increasing frequency of such mails has led chief information commissioner Wajahat Habibullah to consider legal action against those who have named themselves. “The slanders are shocking and unacceptable,” he says.
      Officials at the commission see the mails as intimidating, intended to scare commissioners into giving more lenient judgments against them in the future. “In the larger picture, intimidating us will help all those in the bureaucracy with skeletons to hide,” said commissioner Om Prakash Kejriwal.
      Those who have identified themselves include registrars of two central universities. They have accused an information commissioner of “personal enmities”.
      Both registrars had been sent notices from the information commission after they violated the time frame within which they were supposed to respond with information sought by appellants under the Right to Information Act. “I’ve never met the two officials who accuse me of personal vendetta,” the commissioner facing the accusation said.
      To deal with the mails, including those that come with “threats”, the chief commissioner is seeking help from the National Informatics Centre, which handles software facilities for most central government officials.
      The centre has asked IBM — about to provide new hardware for the information panel’s computing facilities — to ensure that products are compatible with software to help track email senders.
      NDTV Message Board
    • ganpat1956
      By ganpat1956
      Monday, March 19, 2007
      By Sam McBride
      The Northern Ireland Office has been ordered to respond to a Belfast Telegraph Freedom of Information (FOI) request made more than six months ago.
      A judgment by the Information Commissioner has given the NIO 35 days to provide a response and warned that failure to comply with its decision may lead to High Court action.
      The request, for details of official entertainment by Secretary of State Peter Hain, was made on August 22, 2006.
      The Commissioner's decision notice states that, as well as not answering the initial request, Mr Hain's department twice failed to answer written communications from the Information Commissioner in January.
      The legal document states: "The Commissioner wrote to the NIO on January 30, advising that he had received further complaints from this complainant regarding unanswered requests made to the NIO.
      "The Commissioner again asked the NIO when it would respond to the complainant's outstanding request. No response was received."
      In October, the NIO said the request had not been received and asked for it to be resubmitted. It later claimed the request in August may have been identified as junk email.
      But the Commissioner's judgment notes: "This does not account for the fact that the complainant did send other emails to the NIO email address which were received."
      The order, signed by Assistant Information Commissioner for Northern Ireland Marie Anderson, concludes the NIO has not supplied the information or a refusal notice and has therefore failed to comply with the law.
      Last month, the Information Commissioner said that, following several failures in handling FOI requests, the NIO's compliance would be monitored.
      NIO ordered to meet Telegraph request - Local & National - News - Belfast Telegraph


  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy