Jump to content

Report Card on the Performance of Information Commissions in India

According to a “Report Card on the Performance of Information Commissions in India” prepared by Satark Nagrik Sangathan (SNS) and Centre for Equity Studies (CES), transparency is a key to promoting peoples’ trust in public institutions. The assessment found that several ICs were non-functional or were functioning at reduced capacity, despite large backlogs, as the posts of commissioners, including that of the chief information commissioner (CIC), were vacant during the period under review. In many cases, the appointments of information commissioners were found to be set aside by courts due to lack of transparency in the process of appointment and for being in violation of the provisions of the RTI Act and directions of the Supreme Court.
In addition, the Report, says, “By failing to disclose information on their functioning, ICs continue to evade real accountability to the people of the country whom they are supposed to serve. The legal requirement for the central and state information commissions to submit annual reports every year to Parliament and state legislatures respectively, is to make, among other things, their activities transparent and available for public scrutiny. However, very few ICs fulfil this obligation, and even fewer do it in time”. 
As part of the assessment, and in order to access information about the functioning of information commissions, both SNS and CES filed RTI applications with the 28 state information commissions (SIC) and the Central Information Commission (CIC). A total of 169 RTI applications were filed seeking identical information from all the 29 information commissions. The RTI applications were tracked to assess how each information commission performed as a public authority, in terms of maintaining and disclosing information. Three information commissions from Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu did not respond to, or even acknowledge, the RTI applications filed within stipulated time.
"Several ICs, like from Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Maharashtra, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh rejected requests for information invoking provisions seemingly in violation of the RTI Act. In all these cases, an appeal was filed against the denial of information. However, till the time of publication of this report, the requisite information had not been disclosed," the report says.
Apart from Tamil Nadu, three State Information Commissions (SICs), Odisha, Sikkim and Kerala returned the RTI applications citing procedural deficiencies.
Only 13 out of 29 ICs provided full information in response to the RTI applications filed as part of this assessment. Of the 107 chief information commissioners for whom data was obtained, the overwhelming majority (84%) were retired government servants including 67% retired Indian Administrative Service (IAS) officers and another 17% from other services. Of the remainder, 10% had a background in law (5% former judges and 5% lawyers or judicial officers).

Resistance from banks in revealing Loan details to corporate entities

The RTI query, sent to the Ministry of Finance, sought details on individual exposure of various PSBs to corporate borrowers. The questions that were asked in the RTI query sought information on the loans given to the Reliance Industries, Adani Group, GVK Group, GMR and Jaypee Group. The RTI was first directed to the Finance Ministry, which then forwarded the RTI request to various banks asking them to provide the information. The RTI had questions on the money loaned to big industrial houses by government-run banks. However, all public sector banks except Andhra Bank and Allahabad Bank have refused to divulge information citing either the 'personal nature' of questions or how they don't fit under the provisions of the RTI Act. 
In their reply to the RTI query, the banks have said that the information available with banks under "fiduciary relationship" is exempted from disclosure.
Read about: Fiduciary Relationship under RTI
While Andhra Bank and Allahabad Bank have disclosed the loans given to big corporates, all other lenders refused to do so. Banks which did not disclose any detail in their reply to the RTI query include State Bank of India (SBI), Bank of Maharashtra, Corporation Bank, Indian Bank, Canara Bank, UCO Bank, Indian Overseas Bank, Central Bank of India, Bank of India and Syndicate Bank. Earlier this month, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley informed the Rajya Sabha that loans worth Rs 81,683 crore were written-off by public sector banks (PSBs) in 2016-17.
Country's largest public sector lender, the SBI, said, "The information sought by you under point number three to eight is the third party personal information held by the bank in a fiduciary capacity, the disclosure of which is not warranted for any larger public interest and as such is exempted from disclosure."

Upper limit of Rs 50 imposed on RTI Fee by Supreme Court

The Supreme Court fixed on Tuesday an upper limit of Rs 50 as application fee that government authorities can charge those seeking information under the right to information (RTI) act, the country’s transparency law.
Also, a bench of justices AK Goel and UU Lalit said public authorities cannot ask for more than Rs 5 for each page as photocopying charge, and an applicant need not mention the “motive” while filling out the application form.
The order came on petitions challenging high fees set by different public bodies, including high courts and state assemblies.
The decision can be downloaded from here:

43 years for RTI case finalisation in West Bengal- study

A biennial study conducted by Satark Nagrik Sangathan and Centre for Equity Studies has revealed a grim picture of RTI Act implementation with waiting time at information commissions running in years and commissions in several states becoming non-functional owing to unfilled vacancies. The study has found that if an RTI appeal were to be filed in West Bengal state information commission on November 1, 2017, it would be disposed of in 2060 – after 43 years. In Kerala, it would take six years six months and Odisha 5 years 3 months. The main reason for such a long waiting time is the reduced number of information commissioners that commissions are working with. 
The report has brought out, what it calls a “concerning trend”. The information commissions, which are the last resort for the common man to complain against wrongful denial of information, are increasingly returning cases. The highest number of cases have been returned by CIC, followed by Gujarat, Assam and Uttarakhand.


Before the detailing of Forum rules, it is important to mention here that RTI INDIA website is only meant for RTI awareness and generating interest of Right to Information amongst our members and readers. Therefore, our primary guiding light is Awareness of RTI. All rules should be viewed with the vision of ours. 

This section should be treated for all sections of the RTI INDIA website, and all below-mentioned rules apply to posting content on all parts of the website. RTI INDIA website and it's forum, blogs, and other segments are public forum except otherwise decided or is restricted by our forum rules. All posts made by you are available for everybody at large and are actively indexed over our search and other search engines. Hence any content posted by you is publicly available and is a PUBLIC POST. All your consequences of placing any content solely lie with you and only you. Any complaint received in reference to the content posted by you shall be sole responsibility of you to defend your content any our site.

  1. All Posts/ threads/ blogs/ uploads/ images/ articles/ newsletters/ members profile once made or created by the member at RTI INDIA including forums, blogs, directory and elsewhere become the integral property of the RTI INDIA website. The content once posted cannot be deleted/edited/modified by the poster except otherwise decided by us. Therefore, the user must be careful before posting any content which may harm him or others in any way during the time of posting or in future. We shall not take any responsibility of any harm which accrues to you or anybody because of the content posted by you. It should be remembered that RTI INDIA is a public forum (unless otherwise decided), and most of the content will be searchable.
  2. While we do not want to limit the spirit of civil disagreement, we reserve the right to decline to publish unacceptable content and to remove it if we find it on the site. We also reserve the right to edit submitted content, as we deem necessary. These edits will typically consist of censoring obscene or inappropriate language and correcting bad language, or anything which is in contravention to the forum rules, terms, Privacy and interest of the website.
    There are many contents which we from time to time decide about its acceptability, as listed below:
    • Statements that are made and are intended as a personal attack or are abusive, harassing, or threatening. Any sort of disguise posting to attempt such acts shall also be considered as against this forum rule.
    • Any content is seemingly written to defame, belittle, inflame, irritate, in the nature of grievance settlement, knowingly false statements or are based on facts which cannot be verified by us.
    • Information about another user or another individual who is not represented at the forum to defend, or his right to privacy may be affected.
    • Irrelevant statements, SPAM, or unsolicited advertising.
    • Materials that violate the copyright, trademark, or trade secret rights of others that are not otherwise authorized by law, such as fair use
    • Statements that trick or attempt to entice users into visiting a potentially malicious, harmful, external link or downloading a piece of malware
  3. Notwithstanding anything contained above, any content which according to our understanding shall harm the reputation of our website
  4. Site administrators and/or moderators shall determine what is “unacceptable content” on a case-by-case basis. We reserve the right to change these standards at any time. We also reserve the right to remove links to unacceptable off-site content at any time.
  5. No request of for editing/deleting/modifying the post/thread/attachment would be entertaining on normal circumstances. On exceptional cases, the moderators exercise the rights to do the needful on their full discretion. All such requests would only be processed in minimum 3 working days or by the time specified explicitly by the team members by email communication within three days of receipt of the request. All such request should be addressed to moderators of the forum. In case no reply is received from the forum, you may write to admin@rtiindia.org.
  6. RTI India forums and Blogs cannot be used to Name any person in particular. Especially, we do not allow posting of the name of Public Information officers / Appellate Authorities / Information Commissioners or others except as otherwise require to bring out the content.
  7. Also, we do not allow discussions on the personal competence of CIC/ Information Commissioner and any remarks on individual decision making of Public Information Officer/ Officers/ CIC/ Information Commissioner or Hon'ble Judges, however discussions on the decisions is allowed to an extent to bring out the critical analysis on the issue. All posts should be made, as far as possible with an intention of bringing only the content and matter related to Right to Information Act. We strongly discourage any posts content propagating in contravention to above and we actively pursue moderating such posts made by anybody over our site.
  8. We do not allow terms for example like 'Officer is corrupt', 'Public Information Officer do not know this', 'the Decision is wrong' e.t.c which are allegations and presumptions in nature. No Post shall be made alleging Officer, Organisation, department, Ministries, Individuals in any manner. There are multiple instances, when email contents are posted over our website with personal allegations, and are being quoted at our site supporting documents for post being made. No such methods of disguise posting which is in the nature of allegations shall be allowed.
  9. RTI India cannot be used as platform by any means to demean Central / State or any other Government bodies, Ministry, Department, Office, Officer nor our portal is meant for crusade against them.
  10. RTI India does not support any campaign against corruption or otherwise nor does any movement against the Government, Organisation, Ministries, Department, Units, Government Officers, Government Servants, or any Official or individual citizen.
  11. We do not allow posting of telephone numbers, postal address, email address or any other personal details of either the poster or of any other in the forums, Blogs, Guide or any other public accessible place. Any personal communications to be made can be done through the use of Private Messages or through email system of RTI India. The RTI INDIA team will actively pursue removal of such details. Because of the sheer number of posts, it may not be possible to moderate all the posts, and therefore, each member is requested to report posts and content which breaks the rules.
  12. No external links to any sites is allowed at the portal. We also do not allow external site links in the signatures for registered members. if we find any external link posted in the signature or in the forum post we would delete it with or without notice. Members cannot post external links to any site which are flaming, inflammatory, dis-respectful, which are in the nature of allegations or against individual(s). Only helpful links which help in RTI knowledge can be posted after explicit approval of the RTI INDIA Team. No appeal lies to restore or insert any links over any part of the website.
  13. No advertisements either in the post nor in the signature.
  14. No selling of material, books or any other thing which indicates any commercial motives, without explicit permission from RTI India team.
  15. All posts should be made in the name of the author. However, we do allow users to keep it's privacy intact in so far as public posting is concerned. However, our system tracks the IP address of your network, to keep record of your activities. Therefore in case of any violation of any Government rules and regulations, we have the technologies and competence to track the IP address and location thereof of the user and would cooperate with the legal authorities for the same.
  16. No blaming, abuse and no arguments.
  17. Public discussions of staff decisions are not permitted on the site. If you have any concerns or queries relating to a staff decision, please take it up in private with a member of the site team via PM or write to us here admin@rtiindia.org. Also we do not permit rating or comparison with other sites. We however, let members critically review, evaluate and help us improve with our own standards and previous status.
  18. All members must be treated in a respectful and adult manner. All members should respect and adhere to the promotion of harmony within the community. Do not attempt to disrupt the community in any way.
  19. No "Flaming". Please do not post any messages that harass, insult, belittle, threaten or flame another member or guest.
  20. No "Trolling". Please do not post any topic that disrupts the peace and harmony of this board. Don't create meaningless threads with the sole purpose of starting a dispute. This includes messages in profiles and signatures.
  21. No "Spamming". Please do not double post or cross-post the same message in multiple forums. You will not mass-PM or mass-email multiple members of this site with the same message. You will not post for the sake of increasing your post count or "install" count.
  22. No "Bumping" (Your threads/posts): Please do not repeatedly bump your threads to try and get attention. Most members of the site are not online 24 hours a day and so will not see your post the instant it is made. Do not bump a thread within 24 hours, and not more than twice a week.
  23. No "Bumping" (Other's threads/posts): Before replying to a thread, take notice of the last post date. Try and avoid replying to posts more than 6 months old. If you have a similar question and cannot find the answer, create your own thread.
  24. No Offensive Material: Please do not post messages that are obscene, vulgar, sexually-orientated, hateful, threatening, racist, sexist, discriminatory, and/or otherwise violate of any local or international laws. This includes links in your signature, profile, posted images, photos and avatars. Staff will ultimately decide if something is appropriate or not.
  25. Please note that this is a PG-13 rated site and therefore is meant to suitable for all ages, including under 13s with parental guidance/permission.
  26. No spreading of any copyrighted material is to take place on this site without the express permission of the copyright holder, which must be attached to the material.
  27. No Trading: This site is not a marketplace.
  28. No posting messages anywhere on this site that are primarily for the promotion or advertising of any website, forums, email address, business, MLM, activity, or other entities that you have an affiliation with (ie. no self-promotion).
  29. All the Blog Posts may be moderated before they are published. All blogs should follow the above guidelines. There should be no mention of names of Public Information Officer, officers, individuals in the post, it should be related to the RTI, we do not allow public mobilization, news posting, and flaming at any blog. We reserve the right to approve, delete, edit, modify the content and attachment of the blog post. Similarly, all blog comments are moderated and are subject to moderation by our team members.
  30. All Uploads made at the Directory segment need to follow guidelines mentioned in the directory segment.
  31. RTI INDIA Owners, Administrators and Moderators reserve the right to promote any content posted in the website to law segment, blogs, social networking sites and in articles without any notice. However, on request or complaint, the same would be modified, deleted or severed according to the wisdom of RTI INDIA owners, administrators or moderators.
  32. All news comments may be moderated before they are published and are subject to the above guidelines enforced by our moderator team
  33. Members are requested to bring into our notice any posts made in contravention of these rule as soon as possible. We reserve the right to moderate, edit, modify, and delete the threads and Posts with or without informing the thread/post owners or others. 

We also reserve the right to warn, give infractions, Publicly give warning, Ban or even delete the Member in case the Forum Rule is broken or is believe to threaten the peace of the community and existence of website cause or otherwise. No appeal lies after the decision is made either to Site Administrators, other 3rd Parties to restore the Thread/Post/Member. 
If any of the above guidelines are not followed by any of the RTI India members, we reserve the right to delete, split, warn, or edit the post or ban or delete the member itself. If you find any violation of above terms kindly report to us at the form available at the website, personal message to the member, by sending a message to @rtiindia at twitter or if above methods fail, directly writing to us at [admin AT rtiindia.org]

You should read our User Agreement in conjunction with the forum rules for using our site. If you do not agree to above rules, you are advised not to register an account with us and to leave the website with immediate effect. 
RTI India Team 

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy