Central Information Commission taking recourse to the Delhi High Court Judgement, Union Of India And Ors vs Adarsh Sharma of 9 October, 2013 directed Information from Exempted Organisations to be given 'to an extent possible'.
This was decided even though the Exempted organisation submitted that information was denied as per Section 24(1) of the RTI Act, were-in CRPF is exempted from the purview of the RTI Act, except when the information pertains to allegations of corruption and human rights violations.
Information from Exempted Organisations
Central Information Commission quoted the High Court Judgement as follows:
However, the High Court of Delhi in W.P. © 7453/2011 dated 09.10.2013 (Union of Indian vs Adarsh Sharma) had held that:
“5. …….if an information of the nature sought by the respondent is easily available with the Intelligence Bureau, the agency would be welladvised in assisting a citizen, by providing such an information, despite the fact that it cannot be accessed as a matter of right under the provisions of Right to Information Act………. …………………………
It is again made clear that information of this nature cannot be sought as a matter of right and it would be well within the discretion of the Intelligence Bureau whether to supply such information or not……...”
The decision of the CIC can be read here! You can also read various Supreme Court and High Court Judgements at our wiki here http://www.righttoinformation.wiki.