Jump to content

Leaderboard


Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation since 04/22/2019 in all areas

  1. 2 points
    Certainly, you have done a crime. But your motive is not for any unlawful gain to you or unlawful loss to anyone. Though your friend's letter can not erase/wipe your crime, he is the affected person, and if he has no objection, nothing can happen to you. Do not fear and always use your own name. If you are worried about your safety, request your friend to sign his name as an applicant. Keep silent and nothing can happen. Never do that again.
  2. 2 points
    Make all attempts, do not assume things, let them state their objections if any. Continue your efforts and do not get doubts as you are not investing any huge amounts. It costs only Rs.22/- for a Registered post.
  3. 2 points
    The citizen has the right to seek information only, and the rest is left between PIO and SIC. The duty of a citizen is using first appeal and second appeal only and making representation to CIC. Represent material facts to IC and seek information. These are not loopholes and in fact, no PIO is caring for RTI sincere implementation. The penalty is left to the discretion of IC killing the spirit of RTI Act and the act is just a paper tiger. which PIO can just blow with his breadth.
  4. 2 points
    Just go ahead and file the first appeal on the following grounds (keep it short and simple): Grounds of the First Appeal: 1. That, the information sought against each of the points of request for information is unique and not a repetition. 2. That, the information sought against each of the points of request for information are all public documents and hence the exemption of section 8(1)(d) (commercial confidence) does not apply. Prayers: 1. Kindly direct the PIO to provide the requested information forthwith. 2. Kindly direct the PIO to provide the requested information free of cost in accordance with the letter and spirit of section 7(6) of the RTI Act.
  5. 2 points
  6. 2 points
    One cannot argue with idiots. Go for second appeal as there is no justification for Public Authority's reason for such denial.
  7. 2 points
    Unfortunately every citizen is having his own personal matters to be taken care of and hardly have personal time to spend with families at a place like Mumbai. In addition this goondaism and group fights , extortions and threatening are usual. BMC corporators are more powerful than MLAs of other districts. If any citizen is having such time, he should file RTI Application and seek information on full details of unauthorised construction, locational address, present status, action taken, pending in Court and the officials responsible for such negligence in duties. In this forum, I have seen such extra ordinary follow up through RTI and then bringing into logical conclusion through PIL by our esteemed member Mr.Bali and he has contributed more insights into tackling this problem. Because of his vast knowledge, perseverance, he could do that at his personal expenses in Punjab state, but in Mumbai we can never dream of that. Why only Mumbai, it is there in Thane, Kalyan and even in Dombvilli also.
  8. 1 point
    Every vehicle that is permitted by RTO states the number of passengers, weight, checks carried out and must display in painting in the vehicle or outside the vehicle, etc. In case of violations, a complaint can be filed by RTO mentioning the Registration vehicle no.... There may be routine checks on high ways both by Police dept., and every year by RTO for fitness certificate. First, get the details from RTO through certified copies and then report violations. Information solicited: 1. Please provide terms and conditions that a transport vehicle (Passenger/goods transport) should maintain as per the sanction of route permits. such as seating capacity, cargo, first aid box fitness certificate etc,
  9. 1 point
    Have you written on the top as heading Noncompliance of SIC Orders Complaint If not send it once again to SIC. Before Karnataka State Information Commission, Bangalore Decision No: Against: State Public Information Officer,.............. Complainanant:............................ Complaint on Non compliance of SIC orders. Appellant submit that SPIO, has not implemented the orders of SIC as referred above, inspite of sending such non compliance notice. Appellant prays for directions to SPIO to provide the information as expeditiously as possible. {lace Date Appellant. I have read the post and noted your concern. But it is not proper to point out the mistake of IC, hence let them realize the mistake in their orders through this complaint. Also file fresh RTI Application and state the SIC decision. Mark this complaint to spio and enclose a copy of RTI Application relevant to that SIC decision.
  10. 1 point
    In this forum, both PIOs and citizens are treated the same and the spirit of RTI Act is important. Forum is always impartial and members are guiding only on precedents. I appreciate the sincerity of PIO member/FAA as they wish to know the correct position, without denying information on invented grounds and seeking clarification. These kinds of gestures to learn more reduces burden both at FAA and Second appeal level. 1. There are different forms of seeking information. ( like Information in letter form, inspection, copies, and certified copies ) If the information was sought in the form of certified copies, it should be given only in that form. In this specific case, website information downloading is not difficult, but the applicant can not get such certified copies as applications are never uploaded. There are several instances, whenever certain information is required on such card holders, Civil supplies department deleted such information from the website. Advising applicant to download is not improper but not correct without confirming himself whether all that information is really available in the website or not. In one sentence: When certified copies are solicited, PIO has to provide certified copies only. 2. Any document that is received by Public authority to avail welfare schemes becomes a Public record with authority and it is no more personal information. PIO must provide such information in the larger public interest as those citizens not deserving such benefits should not avail Govt subsidy schemes. (But in several cases filed by me they have never provided such information and the stock answer is records not traceable, name deleted) 2. Like any other public record, as the information is not exempted, the documents should be provided to the applicant.
  11. 1 point
    You may file two such same RTI applications once again, one in your name, and another in the name of your friend. The one that is filed by you would be signed by you and the other which is filed in the name of your friend would be signed by him. The RTI applications would be exactly the same. Let the PIO pursue his point of view, at the same time, you too pursue your point of view (i.e. first appeal, second appeal, complaint etc.) for seeking the requested information.
  12. 1 point
    HI , I want to know can retailer in India charge for bags (Paper, plastic or jute ) ??
  13. 1 point
    Go for first appeal.as follows: First Appeal dt.....under RTI Act Before:First Appellate Authority,.... Against: PIO........ Appellant:.............................. Brief facts: RTI Application filed on...... PIO provided incomplete, incorrect information vide his letter ref No... Grounds for appeal: PIO has not provided full and correct information. Enclosed details in Annexure. Prayer: Appellant prays for directions to PIO for providing the full and correct information as expeditiously as possible free of cost. Appellant: Annexure to first appeal dt... ___________________________________________________________________________ Information solicited: Provided.....................Not provided against which this first appeal filed now _________1_________________2_________________________3_______________________ 1 2 3 4 thereon. _____________________________________________________________________________
  14. 1 point
    I do not know how your Sunday post appeared in the forum suddenly to-day. The information sought for you is in the larger public interest and connected with welfare measures of Government. You can go for the first appeal, seek hearing of the appeal. Clearly state the facts that their income certificate references, amount, dates with more clarity. This amounts to falsification and corruption. Clearly inform that any application filed voluntarily by citizens becomes a public document and not third party information and SPIO is misinterpreting a well-laid norm. If FAA fails to give the opportunity of personal hearing, enclose copies and report the matter to collector and state as to how Government schemes are being misused, abused by those undeserving citizens and how officials are corrupt and issuing certificates as they like for reasons not known.
  15. 1 point
    is there any rule to exempt Roll tax for the vehicle carrying differently abled person ? plz share the notification copy if available ? Sent from my ONEPLUS A6000 using RTI INDIA mobile app
  16. 1 point
    Members can only guide. Please post your query in open forum, as you have raised the same post "can you help" and I have sent a detailed reply. We shall always try with all sincerity.
  17. 1 point
    Investigate into the background of such officer and his financial status, his monthly salary and total assets he has acquired till today, and it's value location, estimate his total income less minimum 33% consumption needs, and whether it is possible to acquire all assets with that value and then file complaint before Anti Corruption dept., with such statement complaining of disproportionate assets in case of state govt and CVC in case of Central Government. For example, his present salary is R.50,000/ and he was working for 10 years his total salary may be Rs.6 lakhs. minus Rs.2 lakhs for maintaining the family and at the most he can save Rs.4 lakhs.. If salary is the only source of income, if he acquired Rs.50 lakh flat without any bank finance, it reflects disproportionate assets. Make homework and elicit such information from his subordinates without stating about your proposed complaint.. Those persons who are subjected to harassment may help you. But, it is my practical experience that those corrupt officials are always cordial with subordinates and treat subordinates very kindly so that they may not turn against him in such ACB cases. Such harassment is internal affair and 90% of the employee's complaint that their bosses harassment, and many of those workers may not be hard working. It is not relevant to you, as employees have their union and they got groups and they know how to tackle such bosses. Do not blindly believe subordinates as the complainant may be liable for irresponsible complaints against public servants.
  18. 1 point
  19. 1 point
    Now that you have become expert and commenced running do not look for support for walking. FAA orders as I understand is directing PIO to collect such information from EESL and not performing a post office job of sending FAA orders meant to him. Make further addendum to FAA stating the misfeasance of PIO who failed to collect the information and instead just passed on the buck as earlier, and continued to harass applicants. Invariably mention all your efforts in you final addendum right from step one, dates of visits, response etc. till PIOs postman job.
  20. 1 point
    Send first appeal immediately as date of PIO response was 25-4-19 and including postal transit period it may exceed 30 days. As a formality just write single sentence in as Point No.3. 3. Please condone the minor delay of a few days as the appellant is preoccupied with some other family/work pressures.
  21. 1 point
    Make a complaint by Regd post with such photographs and other proofs like receipts given by him etc. to Drugs inspector
  22. 1 point
    There may be several reasons including compromise in the form of Hafta. Once it is brought to the attention of drug inspector by a citizen with such proofs of photographs, receipts etc., Drug inspector must take action. The duty of a citizen is only to bring such lapses to higher authorities. The answer by any Government servant is simple, they are having other important works also. Once it is brought to the attention of authorities, not taking action is serious.
  23. 1 point
    How are you Shrawanji hope everything is fine, Please be in touch ! Wishing the entire RTI India team Happy new year 2019 .........😎🤗
  24. 1 point
    Please do not send attachments unless it is most essential, as many readers do not have time to open the attachments, download, read and give such advises to members. Post the facts in brief and up to the point instead of attaching pages and pages or pasting such large data of information which readers find it irritating to read in small mage type.
  25. 1 point
    Now make a further addendum to first appeal stating that PIO has not obeyed FAA orders, wait for the response for two weeks and go to the second appeal.
  26. 1 point
    This is not unusual, but what are the reasons for posting this twice occupying so much space and what you wish to convey through this post- as information is 17 years old (19-4-2002) While making a post, look that someone gets knowledge or readers should learn something out of the post.
  27. 1 point
    First, file another complaint to DC stating that Collector has not complied/obeyed the orders of DC and request him to take necessary action for wilful disobedience of reasonable orders of superior. You can also point out that as it is a criminal offense, not taking action within limitation period may affect the criminal action. DC might have just forwarded the complaint about further investigation/inquiry in the matter. Wait for a month, file a complaint against all the concerned before Lokayukta. You can search website for the laid down process for filing such complaints/petitions against public authority.
  28. 1 point
    Please do not quote in each post, as it increases the space in the thread and it serves no purpose and makes the posts appear longer without any value addition. At this age, you can only pity for poor knowledge of great authority like CVC and mention that CPIO is not providing information in laid down the format of DOPT and not providing mandatory appellate particulars as grounds for your first appeal. Focus only on information and avoid finding small mistakes/ errors though they are violations of DOPT directives. But, it is the applicant's duty as RTI Org member to point out such violation so that he can correct his mistake. While pointing out deviations confine such to mention and your appeal must be simple and directed to information only. it should not appear like pointing out a finger to CPIO. CVC website has given that CPIO and FAA particulars, take some trouble. At least you could bring their attention to such corruption, and the primary objective is already achieved and accountability remains. Good work. Now you are insulating against a port trust complaint that you are a disgruntled contractor, as you are dedicated to other depts., and bringing out larger public interest, which is certainly a plus point when you argue before CIC. You are in the right direction. If you can afford also seek inspection, they will gladly permit you, you will be learning more through their records and can more copies then you hoped for. I have attended CVC inspection,, people are cordial. Also attend CIC hearing, as it gives you the opportunity of knowing the functioning of CIC, and gives you more courage.
  29. 1 point
    Search website of BMC for the prescribed format of application, use that format and paste Rs.10/- Adhesive court fee stamp and seek information as follows: Information solicited: Please provide me the number of structural audits conducted for 2016-17 2017-18 2019-19 under Sec.353 B a)and provide a list of such buildings identified for repairs and restorations as highlighted in the structural Audit report., b)and list of those societies/Buildings that have not effected repairs/renovations complied the audit findings exposing the residents to hazards c)with an action taken on each and every violator. d)and provide list of all those owners/societies who are still occupying the hazardous building in spite of legal action as on this date. 2. Please inform BMC action plan to bring awareness in residents on occupying such hazardous constructions (Like releasing advertisements, display of such hazard before the building, disconnecting water/power etc) First, decide as to how you wish to bring a logical conclusion with that information.
  30. 1 point
    In RTI we have to use the laid down process, If PIO has provided that information in writing, then go for first appeal seeking directions to PIO to provide the details of that work for which the funds were diverted, and the authority that sanctioned the amount, and the authorities that permitted for such diversion of funds and a copy of that approval/permission for diversion. I propose for another RTI if PIO has provided that information.
  31. 1 point
    Never go explore without exhausting all options. Write another letter pointing out the deficiencies in providing information and remind him that it is his duty to provide that information within 30 days from receipt of RTI Application taking the assistance of concerned employees and once again request him to expedite the information. You have not received FAA orders and the options are still open. Make an addendum to the first appeal and immediately make the letter to FAA. ADDENDUM Dt.................(TO FIRST APPEAL DT............) under RTI Act Before: First Appellate Authority,....................... Against: Public Information Officer,.... Appellant: The appellant wishes to report the following as addendum further to his first appeal for which FAA orders were still pending. Developments after first appeal:: 1. PIO on................vide his letter........ provided a list of diagnostic equipment. He deliberately excluded scan equipment from the list 2. For all other queries, PIO has replied that he has forwarded the RTI application to respective departments within the hospital and once he receives the information, he would forward the same to me. Even information regarding a list of people who administer the hospital was not provided Grounds for the addendum further to first appeal: PIO provided incomplete information even after.....days against 30 days time frame. PRAYER: It is the obligation of PIO to collect such information and provide it to the applicant within the time frame stipulated in RTI Act i.e. 30 days. Please direct PIO to provide information as expeditiously as possible free of cost. Appellant.
  32. 1 point
    After filing first Appeal,PIO has responded with the following details 1. PIO provided list of diagnostic equipments. He deliberately excluded scan equipments from the list 2. For all other queries, PIO has replied that he has forwarded the RTI application to respective departments within the hospital and once he receives the information, he would forward the same to me. Even information regarding list of people who administer the hospital was not provided Should I go for SA ?
  33. 1 point
    Please provide clarification as to whether you have sought same information earlier and whether PIO has provided such information and reasons for such denial. After giving such clarification you can explore the possibility of going for the first appeal as CPIO has not justified reasons for the denial and just quoted a section and I do not personally think that CPIO has the information in a fiduciary capacity at any stretch of wild imagination. I am also shocked to know that APIO has denied the information when he is not having such powers under RTI Act. Only designated CPIO can provide or deny information and API's denial is most unjustified and illegal, his action is ultra vires. We all missing the most valuable services of Super Moderator Raveena as she is the authority in Railway matters. Kindly search in her profile and send the query as a personal message, as she is the most competent person that can provide authentic guidance in matters relating to Railways.
  34. 1 point
    DUPLICATE THREAD BY SAME MEMBER ON SAME ISSUE. MODERATORS KINDLY MERGE BOTH THREADS.
  35. 1 point
    Janab, Think practically. I am a stranger and I am not aware what is that information and the document you have solicited. It is you that suspect that that information is available with PIO and he has provided incorrect information that the document sought is not available in the file. You are suspecting a PIO and you know where that document must have been if it is really available. Members can only provide general guidance and exploring such possibilities rests on the member.
  36. 1 point
    You can do both things. File Fresh application with that authority that may be having such medical report as they might have submitted the same either to Police or some dept., Ask your friend to file a fresh application seeking information as follows: Information solicited: 1. Please provide a copy of the Register that states the receipt/issue of Accident /OP Ticket/Medical examination on...... Continue the first appeal stating the facts known to you and pray for directions to PIO for providing the information and for inspection. In India, you have several touts and unofficial channels that work for a fee to get any information without any difficulty manage with them by personally contacting them.....
  37. 1 point
    Go for the first appeal to FAA. Read Sec.7 (1)in Telugu. The act stipulates rejection can be made only under reasons specified in Sec.8 or Sec.9. Sec.8 or Sec.9 never state that rejections can be made with such reasons as "the record has been searched but could not be traced" is a valid reason, every Public information officer can reject such application stating such invented reason for rejection. First Appal dt....under RTI Act Before: First Appellate Authority, State Archives and Research Institute, Telangana............. Against: State Public Information Officer, State Archives and Research Institute, Telangana.......... Appellant: Grounds for Appeal: SPIO has rejected the RTI application stating a reason unknown in RTI Act. Sec.7 (1) stipulates rejection can be made only under reasons specified in Sec.8 or Sec.9. SPIO has invented a reason for denial unknown in RTI Act. It appears that the concerned officer is not aware of fundamentals in RTI Act and DOPT prescribed a form of response/denial and SPIO failed to provide further appeal procedure as per Sec. 7 (8) SPIO is most irresponsible in his duties and acted negligently. PRAYER: Appellant prays for directions to SPIO for tracing the record and for providing it as expeditiously as possible without any fee. Appellant also prays for directions to PIO on Sec. 7 (8). Appellant. Encl PIO response xerox self-attested on back of this first appeal.
  38. 1 point
    Registration number is mandatory. Insurance is not. As you have filed the second appeal, let Commission say it is confidential information not to be shared. Providing information prior to such visit may be confidential. But providing it after the trip becomes an entry in a register and must be provided.
  39. 1 point
    Immediately send a confirmation if you wanted to appear for a hearing. "As per conversation with Shri.................on......................at...................., the appellant of First Appeal dt....... was asked to appear for the first appeal for hearing on....................at....................... Please send a written confirmation to the appellant by email to....... and ensure PIOs presence as the burden of providing information is on PIO" The experts in the forum always advised that attending personal hearing brightens the chances of getting information at the earliest and saves a lot of further steps in second appeal, time and money. Appearing for hearing is not mandatory. It is a courtesy to inform FAA to report your inability for hearing.
  40. 1 point
    I am currently working in a village as a school teacher and found that though there is a PHE in that area, but water never pour from the tubes which are placed all over the places. The villagers said that the Pipe lines were destroyed when there was a constriction of Road in that area, and the PHE department never repair them. Now for last three years they are really struggle for the water in times of summer and early winter. The villagers have said that the PHE is running in records and the contactor received the remuneration and diesel regularly but never inspect the matter.I have submitted an application to the PHE department regarding the matter, but till no response from them. Please help me out how to file the RTI draft regarding the matter. Thank you.
  41. 1 point
    Always adhere to the sound principle of focussing on information and making the second appeal as brief as possible. If PIO and FAA denied that information and not considered as Life or Liberty clause, then you can submit the same during arguments in personal hearing. If you have quoted the citation to PIO and FAA, then you can attach the same to your present second appeal. However, there is no bar or prescription for enclosures in the second appeal. In second appeal the mandatory documents to be shown as chronological index events at the beginning of the second appeal with self-attestation. (Attested true copy and below signature for all documents) 1.RTI Application dt...........with service proof Page No. 2. SPIO response dt........... Page No. 3. First Appeal with service proof dt........... Page No. 4.FAA orders dt........... Page No. 5.Second appeal dt...........service proof to SPIO. Page No. If the response is nil, you may indicate opposite to the date/page no as NIL.
  42. 1 point
    Your drafting is good and even an expert can not suggest better points. Just mention the subject matter with more clarity in one sentence. Complaint dt........................from......................against dy. Registrar, orders Ref....................No....................Implementation status. The queries are more than enough. Congratulations for perseverance in focussing on many issues as required in RTI.
  43. 1 point
    Wait for 45 days from date of delivery of your first appeal. Please go through sec.19 and 20 thoroughly preferably in your mother tongue. Use the same format as the second appeal and if SIC has prescribed a format adhere to that format and provide copies to SIC as per their rules and regulations. (Normally one set is enough) Before: State Information Commission,............................. (No............................................................) Second Appeal dt.10th Mar 2018 under RTI Act Public Authority: 1)SPIO"BAU, Agra BAU, Agra- Date of RTI dt..... Self-attested copy encl as No.1 Page No.2 with service proof. 2.First Appellate Authority, BAU, Agra: Date of FA........Self-attested copy encl as No.2 Page No.4 with service proof Appellant:: Grounds for Appeal: SPIO has neither provided information nor rejected information for RTI Application dt..........till today. As there was no response from SPIO within 30 days of receipt of the application, seeking information as deemed denial this first appeal was filed on....... FAA remained silent and there was no response. Hence treating the information as deemed denial, this second appeal. Copy of second appeal was sent to SPIO on.......and service proof enclosed. PRAYER: Appellant pray for directions to SPIO for providing the information free of cost as expeditiously as possible, for imposing penalty and recommendation for disciplinary action against SPIO for negligence, deliberate and malafide denial and ignoring statutory obligation. I, solemnly affirm and state that the above facts are true and correct to my knowledge and information. Appellant. Encl: self-attested copies of 1. RTI Application dt...........2.First Appeal dt....... 3.Copy of second appeal service proof. proof.
  44. 1 point
    If you are able to establish larger public interest, you most certainly can file a first appeal under section 19(1) of the RTI Act.
  45. 1 point

    Version 1.0.0

    166 downloads

    The Service book of Government employee can be disclosed under Right to Information Act 2005 With the recent decision of Central Information Commission Service book of Government Employee can be disclosed under Right to Information Act 2005. This means a third party can have access to most of the information about the employee career including disciplinary action, his leave, place of posting etc. A Service book of Government Employee is maintained for every employee from the date of his first appointment. Every step in official life is recorded in it. All the pensionary benefits are sanctioned mainly on the basis of entries in the Service Book. Hence, it plays a prominent role in the timely settlement of pension cases and proper maintenance of Service Book eliminate delay in sanctioning and payment of pensionary benefits. The Service book of Government Employee consists of 2 volumes. VOLUME-I: Volume I of the Service Book is meant for recording the bio-data of the employees and various events of his service. VOLUME-II: The purpose of Volume-II of the Service Book is to place different types of nominees, declarations, pay fixation memos etc. The Service book of Government Employee contains following information of an employee Appointment and joining.Grant of increment or withholding of increment.Grant of Selection Grade.The crossing of efficiency bar.Fixation of pay.Grant of leave.Deputation/ transfer suspension or interruption in service along with details of the period thereof.Reinstatement.ResignationTermination of service along with its reasons.Promotion.Compulsory / Premature/ Voluntary Retirement.Removal or dismissal from service.Reversion.Reduction in rank or pay along with the precise reasons thereof viz. Whether reduction is on account of inefficiency or reduction in establishment or abolition of the post held by the employee.Retirement on superannuation. The Central Information Commission has decided an appeal on Service book of Government Employee with following directions: The Commission holds that service details of Public servants available in the service book cannot be treated as personal information. (File No: CIC/AD/A/2011/000014)
  46. 1 point
    Actually, it is the duty of public authority to upload in the website the marks of total candidates selected and marks scored in order of merit and cut of marks. I sincerely feel that seeking that information is not an invasion on personal issues. There are no restrictions in seeking information under RTI Act, and it is every citizen's right. It is the duty of the PIO either to provide the information or deny information stating such clause and justification for using that section and subsection of Sec.8, as to how informing the marks scored in employment test amounts to invasion on the privacy of such person. Sans that justification, simple denial is deliberately malafide. When transparency and accountability are objectives of RTI, it is the duty of public authority to upload these marks voluntarily. If anyone wants information, simply seek that information, if that information is not provided, then immediately come to the forum stating such reason and justification given. Experts then can guide members in filing first appeal and thereafter the second appeal.
  47. 1 point
    In general, there can never be substandard equipment in high-end products. Before purchasing such equipment, there are many exercises before placing an order. An expert committee makes inquiries, writes to already users about its functioning, calls references from successful bidder, gets opinions of other hospitals in writing, finally the expert committee sanctions while checking all parameters. They mainly take care of initial teething problems, insist for free maintenance during the first year, makes a condition for visit maximum within 24 hours, and even penalize for late functioning. They also maintain a list of those suppliers who are having bad reputation earlier and lists their names in a prohibited list. The second problem is corruption. As getting a break-even point for private hospitals is very difficult as they have to get 100 patients every day and they depend on outside work. Further, due to the change in technology, the latest machines have more features and cost-effective. Even here there are no experts and one technician prepares the report and sends the same to a qualified doctor for his signature. The collector is in charge and a mere reference is more than enough to inquire in the matter. Some hospitals must send email to all concerned and the expert should possibility come maximum within 24 hours and each visit may cost around Rs.10,000/- but for the first year, it is free. There is also lifetime contract say maximum 3 years. Without this equipment, it becomes an ordinary nursing home:, moving a serious patient to an outsider for all those checkups is itself a difficult task as getting ambulance services, waiting and abnormal costs are also posing more troubles to the patient. The proper course is seeking inspection and with a laptop and digital camera prepare a comprehensive report to submit it to the collector and release the report to media if the applicant is genuinely concerned of larger public interest and good use of public money. It takes a minimum of 60 hours for two persons to prepare the report.
  48. 1 point
    Immediately search the website of the Hospital and seek information on the most important aspects touching larger public interest. You have to locate correct Public Information officer, a format of application and amount of RTI fee to be remitted and such mode. If you have any difficulty to find those details, file RTI Application to Nodal PIO, Collector of the district and you will certainly get information, though it may be late by another 5 days. (Hon Collector is such committee member in running all Govt. Hospitals) Ask about the list of all electronic equipment, date of purchase, the amount spent, the source of funds, present position, expenses spent so far, Any service contract entered, machines not being used for such repairs, pending proposals of identified instruments. The most important aspect is whether equipment are being purchased with the maintenance contract, and the period within which company has to attend for repairs, number of cases being referred to outside hospitals, though the equipment is there but in working. (There is large corruption in these aspects, as some government servants neither due to ignorance or purposefully spoil the delicate equipment, and refer the cases to outside and get their unofficial commission on all such references)
  49. 1 point
    hello, i have been getting lot of help from this forum. thought i will take some time to write my success story. - we had this long pending flywor work going on in our neighbourhood for close to 3 yrs. it was handled the tamilnadu state highways dept. filed a strong RTI with the state highways,with 20+ points,back in Jan 2016 and got a satified reply wtih all the details and expected completion by 19th Nov 2016 . guess what, it all happened as stated in RTI and the flyover is now functioning from Dec 2016. sad part - this construction is in outskirts - and one of my questions was - how many RTI were filed in regards to this construction work - the reply was NONE in the last 3 yrs. I personally feel this as a success, regardless of what impact that my RTI may have caused on the officials involved in the construction. I now have 2 more RTI pending to be sent out - one for another flyover in chennai and the other for some corruption and menace that i could sense at a NATIONAL HIGHWAY TOLL closely to my location. I expect success in ths as well.
  50. 1 point
    You can file application seeking for information, inspection with assistance of an expert and for obtaining certified copies. Every information whether it is a policy or not has to be given if not rejected specifically quoting exemptions under Sec.8 or 9. But you can seek copy of file recordings, and report if any but not entitled to questions against of Public Authority through RTI. 1, It can be accepted by some and it depends on prominence of the news papers. Please try to file RTI application before a Public library and ask them to give certified copy of such and such matter in News paper of that day and Page.No. (just my idea) 2.Yes you can seek information on Budgeted projects, estimation etc., under RTI Act. 3.Depending on informatin solicited, PIO will provide you the file in which information sought by you is supposed to be available. If information is not available, then you can then and there make a gist of documents not available in the file and get ack of PIO on your office copy. 4.You can seek concerned file no by naming specific issue/information. Inspection meaning has to be construed that PIO has to provide information in files pertaining to the queries made by you before him.
This leaderboard is set to Kolkata/GMT+05:30

Announcements

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy