Jump to content
News Ticker
  • NPAs under PM Modi's Mudra scheme jumped 126% in FY19
  • shows RTI
  • RTI query reveals banking frauds of ₹ 2.05 Trillion reported in the last 11 years
  • 509 per cent rise in cases under child labour law: Study
  • The Central Information Commission has allowed disclosure of file notings on the mercy petition of a rape and murder convict, rejecting the government's contention that the records cannot be disclosed as these are privileged documents under Article 74(2) of the Constitution.
  • Electoral bonds worth over ₹5,800 crore were bought by donors to fund political parties between March 1, 2018 and May 10, 2019, a Right to Information reply has said.
  • Don't pay 500/- for answer sheet now- Supreme Court says if Answer sheet is asked under RTI, RTI Fees will be governed

Search the Community

Showing results for tags 'poorimplementation'.



More search options

  • Search By Tags

    Type tags separated by commas.
  • Search By Author

Content Type


Forums

  • Request for Community Support
  • Connect with Community
  • Learn about RTI
  • Website News & Support
  • Read RTI News & Stories
  • RTI Act Critics's RTI Act Critics Topics
  • Fans of RTI India's Fans of RTI India Topics
  • Insurance Consumer's Insurance Consumer Topics
  • Activists of Transparency and Accountability's Activists of Transparency and Accountability Topics
  • Issues with BWSSB's Issues with BWSSB Topics
  • Law+Order-Bangalore-32's Law+Order-Bangalore-32 Topics
  • Issues With Electricity Board's Issues With Electricity Board Topics
  • RTI Activists's RTI Activists Topics
  • YOGA's YOGA Topics
  • help each other's help each other Topics
  • forest and wild life's forest and wild life Topics
  • Indian Police Officials not following Cr.P.C.'s Indian Police Officials not following Cr.P.C. Topics
  • RTI Activist+Politics's RTI Activist+Politics Topics
  • hostels and lodging places's hostels and lodging places Topics
  • RTI Activists in Rajasthan.'s RTI Activists in Rajasthan. Topics
  • RTI info warriors in Haryana's RTI info warriors in Haryana Topics
  • DisABILITY Rights and RTI's DisABILITY Rights and RTI Topics
  • Govt Servant, Local Bodies or PSU Employees using RTI.'s Govt Servant, Local Bodies or PSU Employees using RTI. Topics
  • Eco club's Eco club Topics
  • Self Employment in Sport's Self Employment in Sport Topics
  • RTI related to land issue's RTI related to land issue Topics
  • Open SourceTechnology support to RTI's Open SourceTechnology support to RTI Topics
  • TRAP group's TRAP group Topics
  • Odisha RTI Activists's Odisha RTI Activists Topics
  • right to information activists's right to information activists Topics
  • Mumbai's Mumbai Topics
  • RTI ACTIVISTS FROM KARNATAKA's RTI ACTIVISTS FROM KARNATAKA Topics
  • Chartered Accountants's Chartered Accountants Topics
  • ngosamachar's ngosamachar Topics
  • Growing INDIA's Growing INDIA Topics
  • we are all friends.'s we are all friends. Topics
  • RTI for Government employees's RTI for Government employees Topics
  • Dhanus - Pending Salaries's Dhanus - Pending Salaries Topics
  • Insurance Surveyor & Loss Assessors's Insurance Surveyor & Loss Assessors Topics
  • Mahamumbai's Mahamumbai Topics
  • FREE LEGAL HELP AND SUGGESTIONS's FREE LEGAL HELP AND SUGGESTIONS Topics
  • M.Sc/MCA and ME/M.Tech's M.Sc/MCA and ME/M.Tech Topics
  • Corruption's Corruption Topics
  • ASSOCIATION FOR HUMAN RIGHTS & ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION's ASSOCIATION FOR HUMAN RIGHTS & ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION Topics
  • MAHARASHTRA- ADVOCATE/LAWYERS's MAHARASHTRA- ADVOCATE/LAWYERS Topics
  • INDIAN WOMEN- LAWYERS /ADVOCATES's INDIAN WOMEN- LAWYERS /ADVOCATES Topics
  • minority engineering colleges in maharashtra's minority engineering colleges in maharashtra Topics
  • AAKANKSHA's AAKANKSHA Topics
  • RTI AGAINST INDIAN AIR FORCE MALPRACTISE's RTI AGAINST INDIAN AIR FORCE MALPRACTISE Topics
  • RiGhTs's RiGhTs Topics
  • ram's ram Topics
  • JVG DUPED CUST.'s JVG DUPED CUST. Topics
  • anti corrupt police's anti corrupt police Topics
  • Save Girl in Punjab's Save Girl in Punjab Topics
  • Rent Apartment in US's Rent Apartment in US Topics
  • RTI Kerala's RTI Kerala Topics
  • maharashtra's maharashtra Topics
  • Right Way Of India(RTI)'s Right Way Of India(RTI) Topics
  • Whistle- Blowers against corrupt India's Whistle- Blowers against corrupt India Topics
  • Navi Mumbai's Navi Mumbai Topics
  • electricity curruption in up's electricity curruption in up Topics
  • SHARE n STOCKS trading's SHARE n STOCKS trading Topics
  • WEWANTJUSTICE's WEWANTJUSTICE Topics
  • Civil Engineers-CAD's Civil Engineers-CAD Topics
  • Nitin Aggarwal's Nitin Aggarwal Topics
  • MEWAT EDUCATION AWARENESS's MEWAT EDUCATION AWARENESS Topics
  • ex-serviceman activities's ex-serviceman activities Topics
  • SSCC's SSCC Topics
  • Remove Corrupt Bueraucrates's Remove Corrupt Bueraucrates Topics
  • jharkhand RTI activist group's jharkhand RTI activist group Topics
  • Suhail's Suhail Topics
  • govt.servant's govt.servant Topics
  • RTI Uttar pradesh's RTI Uttar pradesh Topics
  • anti-corruption team's anti-corruption team Topics
  • Manaism's Manaism Topics
  • Insurance's Insurance Topics
  • sonitpur datri sewa samity's sonitpur datri sewa samity Topics
  • indian youth manch's indian youth manch Topics
  • HUDA Co- Operative Group Housing Societies's HUDA Co- Operative Group Housing Societies Topics
  • youth's youth Topics
  • aastha's aastha Topics
  • RTI for Citizens's RTI for Citizens Topics
  • ALL PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICERS OF INDIA's ALL PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICERS OF INDIA Topics
  • learn always's learn always Topics
  • R.T.I.'s R.T.I. Topics
  • Karnataka Karmika Kalyana Prathishtana's Karnataka Karmika Kalyana Prathishtana Topics
  • Akhil Bhart anti corruption sangathna's Akhil Bhart anti corruption sangathna Topics
  • MBA, business and new entrepreneur.....'s MBA, business and new entrepreneur..... Topics
  • students seeking help's students seeking help Topics
  • UN-DO CORRUPTION's UN-DO CORRUPTION Topics
  • RTI Corporate's RTI Corporate Topics
  • Electrical group's Electrical group Topics
  • V4LRights's V4LRights Topics
  • Pirated software in GOvt oofice and sc hool's Pirated software in GOvt oofice and sc hool Topics
  • Gaming's Gaming Topics
  • WE Born to help's WE Born to help Topics
  • help the elderly citizen's help the elderly citizen Topics
  • NATIONAL ISSUE's NATIONAL ISSUE Topics
  • Ballygunge Government Hogh School Alumni Association's Ballygunge Government Hogh School Alumni Association Topics
  • Corruption free Country's Corruption free Country Topics
  • surajyam's surajyam Topics
  • kanpurvictims's kanpurvictims Topics
  • Railway Group A Services's Railway Group A Services Topics
  • RTI BALLIA's RTI BALLIA Topics
  • Encroachment of public property by private giants's Encroachment of public property by private giants Topics
  • Case Status - Anti Corruption's Case Status - Anti Corruption Topics
  • RTI ACTIVISTS FROM MEERUT's RTI ACTIVISTS FROM MEERUT Topics
  • Aam Aadmi (The Common Man)'s Aam Aadmi (The Common Man) Topics
  • Court Marriage in Punjab's Court Marriage in Punjab Topics
  • ALL's ALL Topics
  • Youth India Social Group (YISG)'s Youth India Social Group (YISG) Topics
  • ye kya fandda h's ye kya fandda h Topics
  • mindset's mindset Topics
  • anti corruption's anti corruption Topics
  • activism's activism Topics
  • common's common Topics
  • state group's state group Topics
  • social help group's social help group Topics
  • landlords of uttar pradesh's landlords of uttar pradesh Topics
  • Concern Citizens Forum for India's Concern Citizens Forum for India Topics
  • edusystem's edusystem Topics
  • Ratna Jyoti's Ratna Jyoti Topics
  • development in indian village's development in indian village Topics
  • technovision's technovision Topics
  • Mighty India's Mighty India Topics
  • Against Corporate Fraud's Against Corporate Fraud Topics
  • Stop crime's Stop crime Topics
  • PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION.'s PUBLIC INTEREST LITIGATION. Topics
  • NVS - Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti's NVS - Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti Topics
  • Authenticated Public Plateform's Authenticated Public Plateform Topics
  • shalin's shalin Topics
  • terminater's terminater Topics
  • RTI Wind Energy's RTI Wind Energy Topics
  • AMICE (INDIA)'s AMICE (INDIA) Topics
  • HELPING HAND !'s HELPING HAND ! Topics
  • Go..................?'s Go..................? Topics
  • Co-Op Housing Society's Co-Op Housing Society Topics
  • we are equal's we are equal Topics
  • Phoenix Deals's Phoenix Deals Topics
  • AHMEDABAD ACTIVISTS's AHMEDABAD ACTIVISTS Topics
  • Theft Cases in chandigarh's Theft Cases in chandigarh Topics
  • Economically Weaker Section Certificate & Benifits's Economically Weaker Section Certificate & Benifits Topics
  • Solar Systems's Solar Systems Topics
  • Get aware about ur Education and related rights's Get aware about ur Education and related rights Topics
  • Save Mumbai's Save Mumbai Topics
  • Complaints to MCD & Delhi Jal Board's Complaints to MCD & Delhi Jal Board Topics
  • ashayen's ashayen Topics
  • unemployment's unemployment Topics
  • Employee Solution's Employee Solution Topics
  • is kanpur university against sc/st's is kanpur university against sc/st Topics
  • URBAN PLANNER PROFESSIONAL's URBAN PLANNER PROFESSIONAL Topics
  • RTI HELP INDIA's RTI HELP INDIA Topics
  • prayatna's prayatna Topics
  • Parking woes's Parking woes Topics
  • Helping RTI INDIA web development's Helping RTI INDIA web development Topics

Categories

  • Uncategorized
  • Section 18 (1)
  • Section 11
  • For Common Man
  • Section 16
  • Section 2(h)
  • Section 8 (1)(j)
  • Simplified RTI
  • Government Employee and RTI
  • RTI Act 2005
  • Success Stories
  • Exempt Organisation
  • DG IT
  • Section 8 (1) (e)
  • Section 2 (h) (d) (i)
  • Supreme Court Decisions
  • Section 2 (j) (i)
  • Section 2
  • Section 8
  • Section 20
  • Section 19
  • SIC Punjab
  • High Court Decisions
  • Section 9
  • Section 24
  • DoPT
  • RTI Awareness
  • Section 6 (3)
  • Section 6
  • Section 2 (f)
  • Opinion
  • Department of Posts
  • Ministry of Railways
  • Departments
  • Ministry of Home Affairs
  • Ministry of Corporate Affairs
  • Ministry of Law & Justice
  • Government of NCT of Delhi
  • Delhi Police
  • Ministry of Human Resource Development
  • Staff Selection Commission
  • Court Decisions
  • CIC Decisions
  • Activism
  • Section 25
  • University
  • Section 7
  • Ministry of Agriculture
  • Section 3
  • RTI Discussions
  • Section 19 (8) (b)
  • BSNL & MTNL
  • Section (1) (d)
  • Section 8 (1) (d)
  • DIrectorate of Education
  • Govt of NCT of Delhi
  • Cooperative Housing Society
  • RTI for School
  • Member RTI
  • Municipal Corporation
  • Ministry of Defence

Categories

  • RTI Directory
  • Important RTI Decisions
  • Other Important Court Decisions
  • Sample RTI
  • Acts & Circulars

Blogs

There are no results to display.

There are no results to display.

Calendars

There are no results to display.

There are no results to display.


Find results in...

Find results that contain...


Date Created

  • Start

    End


Last Updated

  • Start

    End


Filter by number of...

Found 1 result

  1. Poor Implementation and Delays Are Making the RTI Act Redundant, Says Study BY GAURAV VIVEK BHATNAGAR ON 09/11/2016 Studies conducted by Research, Assessment & Analysis Group and Satark Nagrik Sangathan have found that pendency rates have been rising in information commissions across the country, making applications irrelevant by the time they are actually heard. While information commissions (ICs) are mandated to safeguard and facilitate people’s fundamental right to information, two national studies on the implementation of the Right to Information Act, undertaken by Research, Assessment & Analysis Group (RaaG) and Satark Nagrik Sangathan (SNS), have revealed that the functioning of the ICs themselves are posing a “major bottleneck” in the implementation of the Act. Moreover, the commissions are now facing a huge backlog of cases while the petitioners are often left with a very “poor quality of orders”. In fact, the two organisations have stated that this has resulted in a situation where several orders of the ICs have been challenged in high courts and the Supreme Court and resulted in judgments that have shaped the contours of the RTI legislation. At a public hearing organised by the National Campaign for Peoples’ Right to Information (NCPRI) at the Gandhi Peace Foundation, the implementation of the RTI Act and the challenges faced by people in using the law were discussed in the presence of well-known RTI users and activists including chief information commissioner, R. K. Mathur, information commissioner, Acharyulu and former commissioners M.M. Ansari, Shailesh Gandhi and A.N. Tiwari. After listening to the testimonies of the RTI users, made in the presence of NCPRI members Anjali Bhardwaj, Nikhil Dey and Venkatesh Nayak among others, the chief information commissioners acknowledged that long waiting time was a key issue which needed to be addressed. Mathur said listening to peoples’ testimonies made him realise how much people valued the RTI Act and how it was often the only resort in their struggle to access basic rights and entitlements. He promised that the commission will examine and adopt a mechanism to ensure that matters relating to basic rights and entitlements are expedited for hearing by the Central Information Commission (CIC). Earlier, RTI users recorded testimonies of their experiences of using the Act in the context of the findings of the RAAG and the SNS study. Kanso Devi, a resident of Savitri Nagar, spoke about how she filed an RTI application asking for details as to why her old age pension of Rs 1000 per month from the municipal corporation of Delhi was stopped suddenly. When she didn’t receive a reply, she filed an appeal and eventually a second appeal, before the CIC in November 2015. Despite a year having elapsed, the case has still not come up for hearing. Another resident of Delhi, Balraj, narrated the difficulty he faced in accessing information about the status of his daughter, Deepika’s application for the Ladli Scheme. After five years with no word on the status of the application, his wife had filed an RTI application in 2015. Only after the matter reached the CIC in August 2016 did the Delhi government release Rs. 18,500 to Deepika under the scheme, as per the orders of the commission. Similarly, several other people receiving old age or disabled pension spoke about the problems they suffered when their pensions were stopped without any reason or without any information being provided to them. Sanno Devi, a person with speech and hearing impairment, who possessed an Antodyaya ration card, which is provided to the poorest of the poor, recalled how her ration was stopped in 2012 and it was the CIC which finally ordered a compensation of Rs 18,000 each to her and seven others whose ration had been stopped similarly. But the Delhi government challenged the order and took the matter to court. It lost there too but still did not release the compensation amount. It was only after the Delhi high court ordered a compliance of the order in December 2015 that Sanno Devi and others received the compensation amount. All these cases highlighted the importance of the RTI Act in the lives of the poor and the needy. The study had taken into consideration all the 27 RTI Act related orders of the Supreme Court, nearly 300 orders of the high courts from across the country and about 2,000 orders of the CIC and the state information commissions of Bihar, Assam and Rajasthan for a preparation of the study report. Poor quality of orders The studies pointed out that while the Supreme Court had in numerous orders cautioned against the tendency of adjudicators to give cryptic and unreasoned orders, “more than 60% of the orders of the information commissions contained deficiencies in terms of not recording critical facts”. The study revealed that while in the case of the CIC 63% of the orders did not describe the information sought, things were slightly better at 35 % in Assam, but worse off at 73 % in Rajasthan and 74% in Bihar. This, the study pointed out, was “problematic” because, for the concerned public authorities and people, there was no way to find out the rationale for these decisions. “Therefore, passing a non-speaking order, which only records the decision of the IC without providing the reasons for its decisions or other relevant details, is a violation of people’s right to information and goes against the fundamental principles of transparency,” it had noted. Noting that the RTI act was extensively used by the poor and marginalised, the study found that several orders of the ICs were set aside by the courts due to lack of reasoning or because orders were ultra vires of the Act. It also stated that deficient orders prevented effective public scrutiny and accountability of the information commissions and commissioners. Pending cases on the rise Anjali Bharadwaj of SNS told The Wire that what was most worrisome was the huge backlog of cases in the information commissions. “In some states like Assam, on average it would now take about 30 years for a new appeal to be heard. Similarly, in West Bengal, a new matter would come up for hearing after 11 years and in Kerala after 7 years. This is unthinkable as most of the appeals pertain to immediate issues related to basic entitlements like subsidised rations, old age pensions, medical facilities and minimum wages. With such huge delays, it would become meaningless for the applicants to take recourse to the RTI Act for getting any information or to get their grievances redressed,” The study revealed that in 16 information commissions for which data was available, there were 187,974 pending cases as on December 31, 2015. Worse still, this data was showing a rising trend as pendency in the Assam state information commission had gone up by 240% while that in Odisha and Punjab had increased by 60%, in just two years. And this is not all. The state information commissioner of Madhya Pradesh, which had the longest waiting time of 60 years as per the previous report, did not share its data at all this time. Observing that often the huge pendency and waiting time are a consequence of commissioners not being appointed to the ICs, the study has suggested that “there needs to emerge, through a broad consensus, an agreement on the number of cases a commissioner should be expected to deal with every month” and these norms should also be made public so the appellants and complainants know what to expect. Also, the study had demanded that well before a commissioner is due to demit office, the process of appointment of his replacement should be initiated so that the new commissioner joins as soon as the previous one leaves. The study has also called for a review of the structures and processes of the ICs. With the help of a trained cadre of officers, the burden of work will be shared and the process of first communication from the IC can be restricted to 30 days. Hearings become more efficient that way, as the composite position in terms of the grounds for appeal remains with the responses of the public information officers (PIOs). Talking to The Wire, former information commissioner Shailesh Gandhi – who is known to have during his tenure cleared nearly 6,000 cases annually – said “At the time of the selection of the information commissioners itself, a deposition should be taken from them stating that they would strive to clear at least 5,000 cases per annum”. He said in most of the cases, templates can be followed for quick disposal. Gandhi said another prerequisite for quick disposal of cases is adequate staff which should be provided for. Also, he said, payment of compensation for denial of information to the applicants is a quick and sure shot way of reducing litigation. “When I was covering the municipal corporation of Delhi, I ordered a large number of compensations. Ultimately it eased the flow of information and brought the number of applications down,” he recalled. Non-imposition of penalty’s on erring PIOs Bharadwaj also lamented the fact that the information commissions were not imposing penalties of up to Rs 25,000 on the erring PIOs for violations of the RTI Act. She said this provision is meant to ensure proper conduct from the PIOs so that the cases are not delayed unnecessarily and relevant information is also not withheld. The study found that ICs imposed a penalty only for an extremely small fraction of the cases in which the penalty was imposable. Across the sample ICs, the study found that the penalty was finally imposed on only 1.3 % of the cases in which it was imposable. “As a huge proportion of the IC orders were non-speaking or unreasoned or otherwise deficient, the appeals and complaints that have been judged to be such that a penalty was imposable are limited to those where there was a clear case of delay, or where the IC held that the PIO had wrongly denied information,” the study said. It also noted that “the non-imposition of the penalty has many serious implications as it sends a message that violations of the law will not invite any adverse consequences. This destroys the basic framework of incentives and disincentives built into the RTI law and promotes a culture of impunity.” In absolute terms of penalty, the study revealed that of the 1,469 cases, in which it was imposable, the ICs caused a loss of over Rs 2.13 crore. This, it said, extrapolates to an estimated loss of Rs 290 crores annually due to non-imposition of penalty on erring PIOs by the ICs. Lack of transparency The study also found that the websites of most information commissions do not provide adequate information about their functioning. It said of the 28 IC websites it analysed, including that of the CIC, it found that those of two states – Goa and Jharkhand – were not accessible at all, while 8 did not provide information on appeals and complaints received by them; 10 did not provide information on the appeals and complaints pending at the end of 2014 or 2015, while in the case of 7 states the orders for 2016 could not be accessed directly. With many of the sites not providing the annual reports or not being updated regularly, the study has demanded that “each information commission must ensure that all relevant information must be displayed on its website” and that, “as legally required, they submit their annual report to the parliament/state assemblies in time.” The study has criticised the “growing tendency among PIOs and adjudicators to exempt information from disclosure citing sections of the RTI Act that do not allow for such exemptions.” From among the 252 appeals at the CIC, Assam and Bihar, where part or full information was denied, it said, 50% denial was in violation of the RTI Act. https://thewire.in/78983/rti-study-poor-implementation/
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use & Privacy Policy